Macquarie University
01whole.pdf (11.64 MB)

Evolution of planetary nebulae with WR-type central stars

Download (11.64 MB)
posted on 2022-03-28, 13:51 authored by Ashkbiz Danehkar
In this thesis I present a study of the kinematics, physical conditions and chemical abundances for a sample of Galactic planetary nebulae (PNe) with Wolf-Rayet (WR) and weak emission-line stars (wels), based on optical integralfield unit (IFU) spectroscopy obtained with the Wide Field Spectrograph (WiFeS) on the Australian National University 2.3 telescope at Siding Spring Observatory, and complemented by spectra from the literature. PNe surroundingWR-type stars constitute a particular study class for this study. A considerable fraction of currently well-identified central stars of PNe exhibit ‘hydrogendeficient’ fast expanding atmospheres characterized by a large mass-loss rate.Most of them were classified as the carbon-sequence and a few of them as the nitrogen-sequence of the WR-type stars. What is less clear are the physical mechanisms and evolutionary paths that remove the hydrogen-rich outerlayer from these degenerate cores, and transform it into a fast stellar wind. The aim of this thesis is to determine kinematic structure, density distribution, thermal structure and elemental abundances for a sample of PNe with differenthydrogen-deficient central stars, which might provide clues about the origin and formation of their hydrogen-deficient stellar atmospheres. The Hɑ and [N II] emission features were used to measure the nebular radial velocities. Based on the spatially resolved velocity distributions of these emission lines combined with archival Hubble Space Telescope imaging for compact PNe, the kinematic structures of these PNe were determined. Comparing the velocity maps observed by the IFU spectrograph with those predicted by morpho-kinematic models excluded the projection effect from the nebula’s appearanceand identified the morphology of most PNe, apart from the compact objects. The results indicate that these PNe have axisymmetric morphologies, either bipolar or elliptical. In many cases, the associated kinematic maps for PNe around hot WR-type stars also show the presence of so-called fast lowionization emission regions (FLIERs). The WiFeS observations, complemented with archival spectra from the literature, have been used to carry out plasma diagnostics and abundance analysis using both collisionally excited lines (CELs) and optical recombination lines(ORLs). ORL abundances for carbon, nitrogen and oxygen have been derived where adequate recombination lines were available. The weak temperature dependence of ORLs has also been used to determine the thermal structure.It is found that that the ORL abundances are several times higher than the CEL abundances, whereas the temperatures derived from the He I recombination lines are typically lower than those measured from the collisionally excitednebular-to-auroral forbidden line ratios. The abundance discrepancy factors (ADFs) for doubly-ionized nitrogen and oxygen are within a range from 2 to 49, which are closely correlated with the dichotomy between temperatures derivedfrom forbidden lines and those from He I recombination lines. The results show that the ADF and temperature dichotomy are correlated with the intrinsic nebular Hb surface brightness, suggesting that the abundance discrepancyproblem must be related to the nebular evolution. Three-dimensional photoionization models of four Galactic PNe have been constructed, constrained by the WiFeS observations (Abell 48 and SuWt 2) and the double echelle MIKE spectroscopy from the literature (Hb 4 and PB 8). TheWiFeS observations have been used to perform the empirical analysis of Abell 48 and SuWt 2. The spatially resolved velocity distributions were used to determine the kinematic structures of Hb 4 and Abell 48. The previously identifiednon-LTE model atmospheres of Abell 48 and PB 8 have been used as ionizing fluxes in their photoionization models. It is found that the enhancement of the [N II] emission in the FLIERs of Hb 4 is more attributed to the geometry anddensity distribution, while the ionization correction factor method and electron temperature used for the empirical analysis are mostly responsible for apparent inhomogeneity of nitrogen abundance. However, the results indicate that thechemically inhomogeneous models, containing a small fraction of metal-rich inclusions (around 5 percent), provide acceptable matches to the observed ORLs in Hb 4 and PB 8. The observed nebular spectrum of Abell 48 was best producedby using a nitrogen-sequence non-LTE model atmosphere of a low-mass progenitor star rather than a massive Pop I star. For Abell 48, the helium temperature predicted by the photoionization model is higher than those empirically derived,suggesting the presence of a fraction of cold metal-rich structures inside the nebula. It is found that a dual-dust chemistry with different grain species and discrete grain sizes likely produces the nebular Spitzer mid-infrared continuumof PB 8. The photoionization models of SuWt 2 suggest the presence of a hot hydrogen-deficient degenerate core, compatible with what is known as a PG 1159-type star, while the nebula’s age is consistent with a born-again scenario.


Table of Contents

Chapter 1. Introduction -- Part I. Planetary nebulae with [WC] stars -- Chapter 2. Spatially resolved kinematics -- Chapter 3. Physical conditions and chemical abundances -- Chapter 4. Hb 4: a planetary nebula with FLIERs -- Part II. Planetary nebulae with [WN] stars -- Chapter 5. Abell 48 with a [WN]-type star -- Chapter 6. PB 8 with a [WN/WC]-type star -- Part III. Planetary nebulae with PG 1159-type stars -- Chapter 7. SuWt 2 with a PG 1159-type star -- Chapter 8. Conclusions and Future Work -- References -- Part IV. Appendices


Bibliography: pages 387-442

Awarding Institution

Macquarie University

Degree Type

Thesis PhD


PhD, Macquarie University, Faculty of Science, Department of Physics and Astronomy

Department, Centre or School

Department of Physics and Astronomy

Year of Award


Principal Supervisor

Quentin Parker

Additional Supervisor 1

Barbara Ercolano

Additional Supervisor 2

Wolfgang Steffen


Copyright disclaimer: Copyright Ashkbiz Danehkar 2014.




1 online resources (556 pages)

Former Identifiers

mq:37427 2443266

Usage metrics

    Macquarie University Theses


    Ref. manager