Macquarie University

Thesis file(s) suppressed due to copyright restrictions

Reason: On receipt of an InterLibrary Loan Request, placed with Macquarie University Library by another library, we will check if we can supply a copy of this thesis. For more information on Macquarie University's InterLibrary Loan service, please contact







until file(s) become available

Thutmose II: re-evaluating the evidence for an elusive king of the early Eighteenth Dynasty

posted on 2022-11-09, 23:47 authored by Trent Hugler

Thutmose II is an elusive figure in the modern reception of early Eighteenth Dynasty history. Originating in late-nineteenth-century historiography with Kurt Sethe’s ‘Thronwirren’ theory, that postulated an ancient ‘game of thrones’, and Gaston Maspero’s instigation of the ‘sickly king’ paradigm, the historical depiction of Thutmose II painted him as an ineffectual ruler in a secondary role, outshone by his half-sister/consort Hatshepsut during his life and reign. The aim of this study is to re-examine the complex image of Thutmose II, and thereby reach a fresh understanding of his life, reign, and posthumous memorialisation. An inductive data-driven diachronic approach was adopted to establish an integrated chronology of the archaeological, monumental, textual, and iconographic data relating to Thutmose II. Chronological sequencing has enabled a series of patterns to be deduced regarding the changing means of commemorative activity after his death. In concert with the deductive, theory-driven approach of cultural memory, the discussion analyses the concepts of remembering and forgetting in both their active and passive form. Crucially, the interplay of politics and memory in these processes, particularly the function of ‘legitimisation’, is discussed. The main focus of this study has been to differentiate and re-contextualise the posthumously-created evidence for Thutmose II within the dynamic political developments of the Hatshepsut/Thutmose III co-rule and beyond. Through the lens of cultural memory studies, new insights are gained into the political sphere of ancient Egypt after Thutmose II’s death. The conclusion reached is while the posthumous use of Thutmose II’s iconography does not add further to the understanding of his own life and reign, it sheds new light on the time of its installation. This insight allows for a more substantiated and critical position to be taken against the traditional historiography of the king and his lifetime.


Table of Contents

1. Introduction -- 2. Literature Review -- 3. Methodology -- 4. The Life and Reign of Thutmose II -- 5. Remembrance of Thutmose II during the era of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III -- 6. The phenomenon of ‘erasure’ and the process of ‘substitution’: Thutmose II and the damnatio memoriae of Hatshepsut -- 7. The Afterlife and Archivisation of Thutmose II -- 8. Conclusion -- Bibliography -- Appendices -- Appendix 1: Thutmose II’s Nubian Rebellion stela -- Appendix 2: The ‘festival court’ of Thutmose II at Karnak Temple -- Appendix 3: Selected (auto-)biographies of officials mentioning Thutmose II -- Appendix 4: Scenes of the cult of the royal statue from the Šsp.t-nḫ


Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Research

Awarding Institution

Macquarie University

Degree Type

Thesis MRes


Thesis (MRes), Macquarie University, Faculty of Arts, 2021

Department, Centre or School

Department of History and Archaeology

Year of Award


Principal Supervisor

Susanne Binder

Additional Supervisor 1

Camilla Di Biase-Dyson


Copyright: Trent J. Hugler Copyright disclaimer:




223 pages