posted on 2022-03-28, 19:01authored byDanielle Colenbrander
This thesis explores specific reading comprehension difficulties with a focus on the role of oral vocabulary. The first study illustrates the complexities associated with diagnosing reading comprehension difficulties by comparing two widely used assessments of reading comprehension. The second study explores the vocabulary, irregular word reading and oral language skills of a sample of children with poor reading comprehension. The third study presents the results of a randomized controlled trial looking at the effects of an oral vocabulary training program for poor comprehenders. The fourth study presents data from the same children as a repeated measures intervention study with multiple baselines, allowing an exploration of the results of the training program at an individual level. This thesis extends the knowledge of the field by demonstrating that there is variability in the vocabulary skills of poor comprehenders at the individual level, and that poor comprehenders who do not have vocabulary difficulties nonetheless perform poorly on tasks of oral language above the word level. In addition, oral vocabulary training is demonstrated to be successful in improving reading comprehension skills for poor comprehenders with vocabulary deficits, implying a direct causal role for poor oral vocabulary skills in reading comprehension difficulties.
History
Table of Contents
1. Introduction -- 2. Similar but different - differences in comprehension diagnosis on the Neale Analysis of Reading Ability and the York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension -- 3. Exploring the relationship between vocabulary skills and reading comprehension - a look at individual differences -- 4. Understanding the link between oral vocabulary and reading comprehension - a randomized controlled trial -- 5. Individual differences in response to vocabulary intervention for reading comprehension difficulties -- 6. Discussion and conclusions -- Appendices.
Notes
Includes bibliographical references
Awarding Institution
Macquarie University
Degree Type
Thesis PhD
Degree
PhD, Macquarie University, Faculty of Human Sciences, Department of Cognitive Science