‘Regard is to be had’: the meaning of Article 7(1) of the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the international sale of goods from a legislative history perspective
posted on 2024-08-05, 00:47authored byInma C Conde
<p>The Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (‘<em>CISG</em>’) is the international legal framework that enables international sales, removing the legal barriers among countries and promoting legal uniformity. Arguably, Article 7(1) is the most important provision as it establishes the interpretation guidelines that promote uniformity within the <em>CISG. </em>Article 7(1) reads: ‘In the interpretation of this Convention, regard is to be had to its international character and to the need to promote uniformity in its application and the observance of good faith in international trade’. However, this thesis argues that the interpretation of Article 7(1) is itself a legal obstacle to uniformity. The mandate ‘regard is to be had’ which is inextricably linked to its elements ‘international character’, ‘uniformity’ and ‘good faith’ is ambiguous and lead to a lack of uniformity. To address this issue, Article 7(1) should be critically analysed according to its legislative history or <em>travaux préparatoires</em>, a source of interpretation in private international law that overcomes the literal interpretation’s shortcomings. This thesis fills gaps in the scholarship by presenting a comprehensive legislative history of Article 7(1) and a critical analysis on the legal expression ‘regard is to be had’. This thesis states that the <em>CISG </em>should not be interpreted according to domestic law, <em>CISG </em>foreign decisions have strong persuasive authority, and the <em>CISG </em>should be interpreted with the promotion of the principle of good faith between the parties. The legal history of Article 7(1) can help to achieve more uniformity and predictability across the <em>CISG </em>and all national and international laws that have adopted Article 7(1).</p>
History
Table of Contents
I Literature review -- II The 1980 Vienna Diplomatic Conference -- III The creation of Article 6 of the 1978 draft Convention -- IV UNCITRAL sessions and Working Groups – Conclusion
Awarding Institution
Macquarie University
Degree Type
Thesis MRes
Degree
Master of Research
Department, Centre or School
Macquarie Law School
Year of Award
2023
Principal Supervisor
Henry Kha
Additional Supervisor 1
Carlos Bernal-Pulido
Rights
Copyright: The Author
Copyright disclaimer: https://www.mq.edu.au/copyright-disclaimer